Categories
Reading and Film Presentations and Discussion

All the Pretty Horses :Ch4.1 ERA

John Grady, arrives back at Don Hector’s ranch and is welcomed by Antonio. His old friends feed him and gives him shelter, however after a day or two John Grady visits the grandmother who own the ranch and is related to his great love, Alejandra. The grandmother, Alfonsa welcomes John Grady into the kitchen of her home and offers him food. She then begins to relay the message that John Grady may never seen Alejandra again, due to the fact Alfonsa is whom bailed him out of jail. The deal between Alejandra and Alfonsa was that the grandmother would bail John Grady out if Alejandra never spoke to John Grady again. John Grady is disappointment in the way Alfonsa has reacted, because he thought she would have a different view on the relationship based on her background. However, Alfonsa then goes on to tell John Grady her views of the world and the history of her childhood and life. When Alfonsa finishes talking and John Grady makes his plea against her, she is still not listening. However she does offer him a horse and food for his travels away from the ranch. 

The next day, John Grady picks a horse out of the stable and says his goodbye to his friends on the ranch before he takes the open road. While John Gready is traveling he comes across a river and rests for a little while. While he is eating his lunch, children join him. These children asks John Grady questions about his life and give him advice on how to win Alejandra back. After this small interaction with the children John Grady finds a place to stay for the night. When he wakes up the next morning he calls the school that Alejandra attends. Alejandra agreed to meet John Grady. When the two meet up in Torreón, they grab lunch and John grady tells his story about everything that has happened to him. When he finishes talking about his time in jail, talking about the experience that led him to jail, and everything in between. ALejandra begin to tell John Grady that she was the one who told her father that they were “lovers.” Which led him to instead of killing John Grady to call the cops on him. 

The two spent that day and night together, but in the end John Grady was not able to convince Alejandra to run away with him. She apologizes and he apologizes, but she continues gets back on the train and continues her journey.

Categories
Catch-All/Student Discussion Questions

John Grady Cole: Values

John Grady Cole is a young man, around the age of sixteen. He grew up on his family owned farm and resembles a true western boy. This true western boy has a love for horses and independence. When his family farm is coming to an end, John Grady needed to continue his love for the ranch life. With these little actions you can comprise that John has many values. These values include, responsibility, loyalty, and skill (possibly honor). These values do line up with the Anglo Protestant culture in a similar way the Anglo-Saxons believed in loyalty with their sect and within their families, that one can not leave and have a different faith. These people have the responsibility to choose their the right path in life, which is following the Anglo-Saxons values : honor and be loyal to their God. The Anglo-Saxon’s believed in independence, however it was formed and given when they chose the right path toward God. These values are still consistent in American culture today. However they are identified differently. The values, independence, responsibility, loyalty, skill, and honor are showcased differently in each person, but are relevant.

Categories
Catch-All/Student Discussion Questions

Saving Private Ryan-Civil Religion

When I was in grade school, around seventh and eighth grade, my history teacher would always show the beginning scene to this film. It was in reference to our conversation about D-Day, she wanted to give us a visualization of how tragic this day was to the soldiers and America as a whole. Therefore while watching the film, I kept thinking about my grade school days and the lessons I learned. However as the film continued I began to pick up on events that were in reference to our conversation this past week. We mainly talked about civil religion, which was prominent within the film.

When the soldiers headed into fight for America, each of them pray to their own God but also to their nation. This one scene stood out to me the most: the soldier, made it to the beach and began to fire back towards the enemies. Before he took one shot, he said a quick prayer. A prayer for God to give him strength. At the end of his prayer, his words went something like this, “give me strength for America and my nation.” Through this one scene, I was able to completely understand what civil religion is. It is the patriotism and nationalism within each America, it brings each American together under one common theme. The theme being America. In the end, this film was very powerful and related civil religion a great amount.

Categories
Catch-All/Student Discussion Questions

Civil Religion Recap

America is a country, where any religion is welcomed. Therefore ‘civil religion’ is not pinpointed to a direct religion but one that brings Americans a combination of nationalism politicism. Huntington says, “Civil religion converts Americans from religious people of many denominations into a nation with a soul of a church” (106). The Church, being a type of symbol for all religions, rather than a homebase for just one. This Church includes, Protestants, Catholics, Jews, and non-Christians. Even though this Church is to combine nationalism and politics, Christianity has stricken its origins into these beliefs because of the historical significance it has on America.

Categories
Reading and Film Presentations and Discussion

Who Are We? Religion and Christianity : ERA


Chapter six begins with the Pledge of Allegiance and states an argument how the words “under God” should not be presented. Having this phrase in the Pledge of Allegiance is a violation of the separation between church and state. However, the main influence of this phrase is that fact that the United States growth is in constitute towards the Christion religion. 

Huntington speaks about the fact that the Pledge of Allegiance argument was taken to court. He says, “The court agreed that the words ‘under God’ sent ‘a message to unbelievers that they are outsiders, not full members of the political community.’…atheists are ‘outsiders’ in the American community. As unbelievers, they do not have to recite the Pledge or to engage in any religiously tainted practice of which they disapprove…however, do not have the right to impose their atheism on all those Americans whose beliefs now and historically have defined America as a religious nation” (Huntington 82). Overall, America was built on Christian faith, opinions and views have been created because of this religion, which Americans are very prominent about. Even though America is built on this view, does not mean other religions are turned away and neglected, they are equally accepted to an extent. The Pledge of Allegiance is more than just these two words, “under God.” It is a symbol of words that brings our country together and gains respect for those who have fought in the past and those who are fighting for our safety today. 

Huntington’s quote reminds me of when President Trump was elected. At this time I was a junior in high school. Every morning, my school would say the Pledge of Allegiance and prayers, however the very next morning after elections a girl in my grade sat during the Pledge of Allegiance rather than stand. Of course this created drama within the school. Agreeing with Huntington’s opinion, if you view this girl as an atheists then she should not impose her views on those around her. There is a huge significance in defending your opinions, however disrespecting America as a whole is not the way to do it. This correlates with the atheists (along with other religions) wanting to change America’s history altogether by getting rid of the words “under God.” In the end, America historically is a religion nation and will always be documented as one. You are free to practice whatever religion or no religion, however you should still respect America’s history.